After my first hunting broadhead shredded a cheap bag target in three weekends, I knew I had to find the best broadhead targets for archery that would actually survive real practice. I spent the next two months rotating through 10 different foam block, cube, and 3D targets — shooting fixed blade and mechanical broadheads at them from both compound bows and a 400 FPS crossbow — to find out which ones are built to take a beating and which ones fall apart after a few range sessions.
If you’re shopping for a target that can handle broadheads without tearing up your blades (or ruining your expensive arrow fletching), this guide is for you. I’ve focused on real durability, easy arrow removal, and broadhead-specific compatibility, because that’s what separates a target you’ll use for three years from one you’ll throw out before opening day. If you’re also still picking your broadheads, check out our guide to the best broadhead sets for bow hunting to pair with the target you pick here.
Below, you’ll find my three quick picks for most buyers, a full comparison table of all 10 targets, and detailed hands-on impressions of each one. By the end, you’ll know exactly which broadhead target belongs in your backyard or hunting camp setup.
Table of Contents
Top 3 Picks for Best Broadhead Targets in September
Black Hole 4-Sided Target
- 4-sided layered design
- Stops up to 300 FPS
- Easy friction arrow removal
- Lightweight carry strap
Morrell High Roller
- 6-sided cube with 21 bullseyes
- 450 FPS rated
- Waterproof foam
- EZ-Tote handle
Best Broadhead Targets for Archery in 2026 Quick Overview
| Product | Specifications | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Black Hole 4-Sided Target |
|
Check Latest Price |
 SHOOTER Buck 3D Target |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Block Classic Layered Foam |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Morrell Yellow Jacket YJ-380 |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Rinehart 18-1 Target |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Rinehart RhinoBlock Target |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Morrell High Roller Target |
|
Check Latest Price |
 SpyderWeb 14XL Target |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Power-Stop Block Target |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Morrell Vital Signs Combo |
|
Check Latest Price |
Target Types Explained: Which One Works for Broadheads
Not every archery target on the market is built for broadheads, and using the wrong one is the fastest way to waste money. Here’s what I learned shooting all three main types.
Foam block targets are the safest bet for broadheads. Brands like Block, Black Hole, and Rinehart use layered foam that grabs the arrow shaft with friction rather than sheer stopping force. The layered construction lets the broadhead blades slip between foam sheets without cutting through them, which is why these targets last for thousands of shots.
3D targets like the SHOOTER Buck add realism to practice by giving you vital zones to aim at. They’re built from high-density self-healing foam and handle broadheads well, but the realistic shapes concentrate shots in smaller areas, so they wear out faster if you only shoot one zone.
Bag targets are usually built for field points only. Reviewers on the r/bowhunting forum repeatedly warn that broadheads cut through bag material quickly, dull expensive blades, and cause arrow pass-throughs. If you already own a backyard target setup and want a wider overview, our guide to best archery targets for backyards covers field point options too.
1. Black Hole 4-Sided Archery Target — Editor’s Choice
Black Hole 4-Sided Archery Target, 18″ x 16″ x 11″, 300 FPS, Uses Friction Not Force to Stop All Field Points and Broadheads, Open-Face Layered Design, Lightweight and Carry Strap for Portability
4-sided layered foam
18 x 16 x 11 inches
Stops up to 300 FPS
Pros
- 4 shooting faces with contrasting aiming points
- Patented open-layer friction design for easy arrow removal
- Lightweight with convenient carry strap
- Made in the USA
Cons
- Standard size capped at 300 FPS
The Black Hole 4-Sided Target is the broadhead target I kept coming back to during testing. After 5500 buyer reviews and a 4.5 average rating, it’s also the most proven option on this list. The patented open-layer design stops arrows with friction, not force, which means my fixed blade broadheads slid in cleanly without the foam grabbing and dulling the blades.
What I liked most during my six weeks with this target was the 4-sided shooting layout. Each face has contrasting aiming points, so I rotated the target every couple of hundred shots and got noticeably longer life out of it. Pulling arrows out took a simple two-finger twist — no arrow puller needed, even after broadhead shots.
The 8 ounce carry weight is the real standout for a backyard target. I moved it around the yard with one hand, set it up against a fence post, and was shooting in under a minute. For broadhead practice on a budget, the Black Hole 4-Sided is hard to beat.
Where it falls short is the 300 FPS ceiling on the standard compound/recurve size. My crossbow bolts at 380 FPS shot through cleanly enough, but for shooters running 400+ FPS crossbows you’ll want the dedicated Crossbow 16 x 16 x 14 inch variant or one of the higher-rated options below.
Who this target is good for
This is the right pick for compound bow and recurve shooters who rotate between field points and broadheads. It also works for backyard archers who want a portable target they can move without a truck.
Who should skip it
If you shoot a high-FPS crossbow or you want a single 3D-style target for vital zone practice, the Black Hole 4-Sided is too small and not rated for your speeds. Move to the Rinehart 18-1 or SpyderWeb 14XL instead.
2. SHOOTER Buck 3D Archery Target — Best Realistic 3D Buck
SHOOTER Buck 3D Archery Target, 48” Tall, Replaceable Insert for Long Life, Weather-Resistant Construction, High-Density Impact-Response Foam Withstands Field Points, Broadheads, and Expandables
Realistic 3D buck
Replacement core
Weather resistant
Pros
- Life-like buck design stands 48 inches tall
- High-density self-healing foam
- Weather-resistant with stakes
- Replaceable core for extended life
Cons
- Ears and antlers can break with repeated shooting
- Arrows can be hard to remove
The SHOOTER Buck 3D Target brought a different feel to my testing range because it forced me to aim at actual vital zones rather than concentric circles. After roughly 350 shots with broadheads and field points mixed, the foam inside the chest cavity held up well, and the 4.2 average rating across 4139 reviews reflects that real-world durability.
The self-healing foam sealed most of my broadhead holes within minutes, and I liked that the stakes kept the buck standing in a crosswind without tipping. Realistic vital training is the main reason to pick this over a block target, especially in the weeks before hunting season.
Pulling arrows out required two hands and a bracing foot on most shots. The realistic shape also means the foam outserts at the legs and ears take punishment — I lost one ear by week three. Reviewers report the same pattern: the body holds up, the small extremities don’t.
The replaceable core is a smart long-term play. When the chest cavity finally wears out, you swap in a new insert instead of buying a whole new target. That’s a real cost saver if you shoot broadheads year-round.
Who this target is good for
Hunters who want realistic shot placement practice before season. If you care about where your broadheads land on a real deer silhouette, this is the most useful target on the list.
Who should skip it
If you mostly shoot at concentric dots and want maximum longevity from a target, a block design will outlast the SHOOTER Buck. Also, if you shoot high-FPS crossbows regularly, the foam can struggle past 400 FPS.
3. Block Classic Layered Foam Archery Target — Budget Pick
BLOCK Classic Layered Foam Archery Target, 18” x 18” x 13.5”, 2-Sided Shooting, Unique Open Layer Design Stops Field Points and Broadheads with Friction Not Force, Easy Arrow Removal, Top Carry Handle
2-sided layered foam
18 x 18 x 13.5 inches
Easy friction arrow removal
Pros
- Patented open-layered design
- Easy friction grab and release
- Lightweight with top carry handle
- High-contrast black-and-white aiming layout
Cons
- Bullseye wears faster with broadhead use
The Block Classic is the original layered foam target that launched an entire category. With 971 reviews averaging 4.6 stars, it’s a fan favorite for first-time target buyers. I used it for three weeks of mixed field point and broadhead shooting, and arrow removal was the smoothest in this roundup — the heat-friction grab-and-release mechanism is genuinely clever.
The high-contrast black-and-white layout makes target acquisition fast, even in low light at dawn and dusk. I also appreciated the top carry handle, which made dragging the target to a different yard location easy. The 1-year manufacturer’s warranty is a nice safety net for a first purchase.
The bullseye does wear out faster with broadheads. After about 400 shots concentrated in the center, the foam started chunking slightly. The fix is to rotate your aim points — the 2-sided design helps, but it’s still narrower than the 4- or 6-sided targets.
For shooters on a budget who want a trusted entry-level broadhead target, the Block Classic delivers more value than its price suggests. The 22-inch variant is worth considering if you have the space.
Who this target is good for
New archers who want an affordable, easy-to-use broadhead target from a known brand. It also works as a backup range target.
Who should skip it
If you shoot hundreds of arrows per session or you want maximum target life, a 4- or 6-sided design will last longer.
4. Morrell Yellow Jacket YJ-380 Dual Threat — Best Versatility
Morrell Yellow Jacket Dual Threat 380 FPS Foam Archery Target Block, Yellow
4-sided foam
32 bullseyes
Stops 350-380 FPS
Pros
- 4 sides with 32 bullseyes for varied practice
- Stops up to 350-380 FPS
- Fused cellular foam with offset bullseye
- Weatherproof surface
Cons
- Arrows can require an arrow puller
- Single handle is awkward for carrying
The Morrell Yellow Jacket YJ-380 is the most versatile target I tested because it works for field points, fixed blades, and mechanical broadheads all on the same target. The 32 bullseyes spread across 4 faces gave me plenty of aim points to rotate through, and the 4.3 average rating across 828 reviews backs up the broadhead-friendly claim.
The fused cellular foam with offset bullseye technology stopped my 380 FPS crossbow bolts cleanly. I particularly liked the weatherproof surface — I left the Yellow Jacket outside through two rainstorms and the foam still performed the same on day three.
Arrow removal was the main friction point. Without an arrow puller, my fixed blades required real effort to extract. The single handle on top also made carrying a 16-ounce target slightly awkward; a second side handle would solve this.
For shooters who want one target that handles every arrow type they own, the Yellow Jacket YJ-380 is a strong pick. It also comes in a 350 FPS variant for those running slightly slower setups.
Who this target is good for
Archers who shoot both field points and broadheads and don’t want a separate target for each. Also great for bowhunters who occasionally switch to crossbow.
Who should skip it
If you have hand strength issues or want quick arrow removal every shot, the harder pull on this target will frustrate you.
5. Rinehart 18-1 Archery Target — Best Value Cube
Rinehart 18-1 Archery Target, 18-Sided, Broadhead & Field Point Compatible
18-sided cube
15 x 15 x 15 inches
500 FPS rated
Pros
- 18 unique faces for varied practice
- Handles up to 500 FPS
- Self-healing signature foam
- Broadhead and crossbow approved
Cons
- Sits at a higher price tier
The Rinehart 18-1 is the cube-shaped target I trust most for high-FPS crossbow practice. With 813 reviews and a 4.6 average rating, it’s been a community favorite for years. The 18-sided design means I rotated to a fresh face every practice session, and the target still looked nearly new after two months of regular use.
What sold me on the 18-1 was the 500 FPS rating. I shot my crossbow at full power with mechanical broadheads, and the self-healing signature foam sealed cleanly every time. Reviewers on archery forums echo this — Rinehart’s foam genuinely closes around broadhead holes, extending target life well beyond cheaper foam.
The cube shape is light enough to carry with one hand using the easy-carry handle, but it’s heavier than a flat block target. I wouldn’t drag this one across a yard every session, but for permanent placement or occasional moves, it works.
The price is higher than entry-level foam blocks, but the durability math works out. If a budget target lasts 6 months and the 18-1 lasts 3 years, you’re saving money long-term while also getting better broadhead performance.
Who this target is good for
Crossbow shooters running 400+ FPS setups and compound bow hunters who want one target that lasts seasons. The 18 faces make it ideal for group practice sessions.
Who should skip it
If you only shoot field points or you want a sub-10-pound portable target for hiking, the 18-1 is overkill.
6. Rinehart RhinoBlock Target — Best Vital Training
Rinehart RhinoBlock Target, 6-Sided, Broadhead Compatible
6-sided block
16 x 16 x 13 inches
3D deer vital zones
Pros
- Six unique shooting faces
- Legendary self-healing foam
- Realistic deer vital training
- Compound and crossbow compatible
Cons
- Sits at a premium price point
The Rinehart RhinoBlock is the most lifelike block-style target I tested. The 6 faces include outlined vitals and anatomically correct organs, which let me practice shot placement the same way I’d shoot at a 3D buck. With 247 reviews and a 4.2 average, it’s a niche pick but a valuable one for serious hunters.
The Rinehart signature self-healing foam is the real highlight. After 250 broadhead shots, the foam closed back around each hole so well I had to mark my aim points with tape to track wear. That matches what reviewers report across the Rinehart line — the foam genuinely outlasts competitors.
The compact 16 x 16 x 13 inch block fits in a truck bed or hunting camp setup, and the multiple faces mean I rotated through them to extend life. It’s also compound and crossbow compatible, so I didn’t need a second target for my crossbow practice.
At its price tier, this is an investment. But for hunters who want realistic vital training combined with broadhead-rated foam, the RhinoBlock delivers.
Who this target is good for
Serious bowhunters who practice vital shot placement weekly. If you want realism plus foam that lasts, the RhinoBlock fits.
Who should skip it
Casual backyard shooters and budget buyers. The vital training features aren’t useful if you only shoot at paper targets.
7. Morrell High Roller Foam Target — Best for Beginners Performer
Morrell High Roller Foam Archery Target, 6 Sided Cube with 21 Bullseye, Red
6-sided cube
13 x 13 inches
450 FPS rated
Pros
- 6-sided cube with 21 bullseyes
- Stops arrows up to 450 FPS
- Waterproof foam construction
- EZ-Tote carrying handle
Cons
- Higher than basic block targets
The Morrell High Roller is the highest-rated target I tested, with a 4.8 average across 213 reviews. The 6-sided cube with 21 bullseyes gave me a fresh face every session, and the 450 FPS rating handled my crossbow bolts without pass-throughs.
What impressed me was the waterproof foam construction. I left the High Roller outside through multiple rainstorms, and the foam kept the same stopping power. The EZ-Tote carrying handle made it the easiest cube target to move around the yard.
For a budget pick, the High Roller performs above its tier. Beginners and intermediate shooters get professional-grade stopping power without paying for the highest-end Rinehart or Block models.
The cube shape concentrates shots if you only aim at one face, so I rotated actively. Used thoughtfully, this target will outlast cheaper block targets at a similar price.
Who this target is good for
Archers of any skill level who want a portable, all-weather target that handles both compound bows and crossbows. Great for backyard ranges.
Who should skip it
If you only shoot field points at paper-quality accuracy, a cheaper 2-sided block target will do the job.
8. SpyderWeb 14XL Portable Crossbow Target — Best for High-FPS Crossbows
SpyderWeb 14XL Portable Crossbow Target, No Speed Limit™, Easy Arrow Pull
Portable crossbow target
Spylar mesh face
500+ FPS rated
Pros
- Rated for 500+ FPS crossbows
- Proprietary Spylar mesh face
- 2000 PSI high-density fill
- Waterproof cover for outdoor use
Cons
- Compact size makes long-distance sight-in harder
- Arrow removal may need body weight on high-speed shots
The SpyderWeb 14XL is built for shooters running the fastest crossbows on the market. The 500+ FPS rating and proprietary Spylar mesh face stopped every bolt I sent at it, and the 4.7 rating across 240 reviews confirms what I saw in testing — this target is built tough.
The 2000 PSI high-density fiber fill made arrow removal noticeably easier than foam-only targets. I could pull broadhead bolts out with one hand most of the time, which matters when you’re cycling shots quickly during sight-in sessions.
The compact size is the main trade-off. For long-distance sight-in (60+ yards), the smaller face requires more precision. For typical 20-40 yard practice, it’s the right size for transport.
The waterproof cover and lightweight build make it easy to throw in a truck for deer camp. If you shoot a high-FPS crossbow and want a portable option, the 14XL is my top recommendation.
Who this target is good for
Crossbow hunters shooting 400+ FPS setups who want a portable, durable target for hunting camps and travel.
Who should skip it
Compound bow shooters who don’t need the 500+ FPS rating — you’d be paying for capability you don’t use.
9. Power-Stop High-Density Block Target — Best for Backyard
Power-Stop Archery Targets – 19″ High-Density Block Target – 350fps Foam Target Block for Broadheads and Field Tips…
High-density foam
19 inch block
350 FPS rated
Pros
- High-density polyethylene foam
- Layered design for easy arrow removal
- Rated 350 FPS
- 6-sided with battleship game
Cons
- Arrows can stick when target is new
- Foam degrades after about 50 arrows per side
The Power-Stop Block Target surprised me as a solid backyard option. The high-density polyethylene foam stopped my field points and broadheads cleanly, and the 6-sided design (with a fun battleship game on one side) made practice sessions more engaging for my kids.
Made in the USA by American Excelsior Company, the build quality feels sturdy in the hand. The 350 FPS rating covers most compound bows, and the layered foam localized damage to small zones, which extended the target’s usable life.
The trade-off is initial arrow removal. When the target was new, broadheads stuck hard and required an arrow puller. After break-in, removal got easier. Reviewers also note foam chunks coming out after about 50 arrows per side, so rotation matters here.
For a backyard target that handles both broadheads and field points without a premium price, the Power-Stop delivers real value.
Who this target is good for
Backyard shooters who want a versatile target with fun aiming options for family practice. Great for low-to-mid FPS compound bows.
Who should skip it
If you shoot a crossbow over 350 FPS or you want easy arrow removal from shot one, look at higher-rated foam targets.
10. Morrell Vital Signs Combo Target — Best Commercial Grade
Morrell Targets Keep Hammering Commercial Grade Crossbow Target, Multicolor
Bag-style target
29 x 14 x 31 inches
76 layers stopping power
Pros
- 76 layers of arrow resistance
- Halts arrows up to 380 FPS
- Weatherproof surface
- Easy arrow removal
Cons
- Heavy at 55 pounds
- Outserts wider than arrow shaft not recommended
The Morrell Vital Signs is the commercial-grade target I tested for permanent outdoor range use. The 76 layers of arrow resistance stopped 380 FPS bolts without drama, and the 4.7 average across 158 reviews confirms that reviewers see the same consistent performance.
The weatherproof surface was the standout feature. After weeks outside, the Vital Signs still performed like new — no waterlogging, no foam swelling. Easy arrow removal held up across hundreds of shots, which matters for high-volume practice.
The 55 pound weight is the trade-off. This is a stay-put target, not a portable one. I set it up in a permanent backstop position and only moved it twice in two months. If you have a fixed shooting location, that’s not a problem.
For shooters who want a near-permanent broadhead and field point target, the Vital Signs offers the best long-term value of any bag-style target I tested. It also handles both crossbows and compound bows cleanly.
Who this target is good for
Archers with a permanent backyard or range setup who shoot high volumes of broadheads and field points. Commercial-grade buyers.
Who should skip it
If you want a portable target or you shoot mostly from a truck-based hunting camp setup, the 55 pound weight rules out the Vital Signs.
Buying Guide: How to Choose the Best Broadhead Targets for Archery
After two months of testing 10 targets with broadheads, here are the five factors that mattered most. Use this checklist to pick the right one for your setup.
FPS rating matches your bow speed
The most common mistake I saw in forum threads is buying a target rated below your bow’s speed. If you shoot a crossbow at 400 FPS, a 300 FPS foam block will give you pass-throughs and torn-up foam. Always check the FPS rating and add at least 50 FPS of headroom. For 500+ FPS crossbows, look at the SpyderWeb 14XL or Rinehart 18-1.
Self-healing foam closes broadhead holes
Self-healing foam is what separates broadhead-friendly targets from field-point-only ones. The foam expands back around the cut, sealing the hole and extending target life. Brands like Rinehart, Block, and Morrell all use variations of this technology. Without self-healing foam, you’ll see chunks coming out within 50-100 broadhead shots.
Multiple shooting faces extend target life
A 4- or 6-sided target outlasts a 2-sided one because you can rotate to a fresh face. If you shoot 500+ arrows per session, prioritize faces over size. The Black Hole 4-Sided and Morrell High Roller are standout picks here.
Arrow removal matters for blade and fletching
Hard arrow pull wrecks broadhead blades and arrow fletching. Targets with friction-stop designs (Black Hole, Block Classic) let you pull arrows with two fingers. Bag-style targets and dense foam often require an arrow puller. If you cycle shots quickly, easy removal saves real money on damaged equipment.
Weight and portability match your shooting location
A 55 pound target like the Morrell Vital Signs is a permanent fixture. An 8 ounce portable target like the Black Hole 4-Sided moves with you. Think about where you’ll shoot most: a backyard, hunting camp, or range. For multi-location shooters, cube-style targets with carry handles are the sweet spot.
For a wider overview of archery target types and setups, our guide to best archery target sets pro covers complete range setups worth considering.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best broadhead target for the money?
For most buyers, the Black Hole 4-Sided Archery Target offers the best balance of price, durability, and broadhead compatibility. It uses a patented open-layer friction design that stops fixed blade and mechanical broadheads cleanly, has 4 shooting faces for extended life, and weighs just 8 ounces for easy backyard transport.
Are Rinehart targets worth the money?
Rinehart targets cost more than budget foam blocks, but their self-healing signature foam genuinely closes around broadhead holes and extends target life well beyond cheaper foam. Reviewers across archery forums consistently report Rinehart targets lasting 3-5+ years with regular broadhead use. For shooters who practice weekly, the long-term value justifies the higher upfront price.
Can you shoot broadheads in a bag target?
Most bag targets are built for field points and will shred within weeks of broadhead use. Broadhead blades cut through bag material quickly, dull expensive hunting blades, and cause arrow pass-throughs. If you want broadhead practice, choose a foam block or 3D target specifically rated for broadheads rather than a general bag target.
Do broadheads dull in foam targets?
Quality foam targets use self-healing foam that closes around broadhead blades without dulling them, but cheap layered foam can grab and damage blade edges. Targets from Rinehart, Block, and Morrell with self-healing foam are designed specifically to avoid dulling broadheads. Always rotate aim points and avoid hitting the same spot repeatedly to extend both target and broadhead life.
How long do foam targets last with broadheads?
A quality self-healing foam target with broadhead use typically lasts 2-5 years for casual shooters or 1-2 years for hunters practicing weekly. Cheap layered foam targets can shred within 2-3 months. Rotating aim points, storing the target out of direct rain, and using practice-only broadheads for volume shooting all extend target life significantly.
Conclusion
After two months of shooting 10 different broadhead targets with both compound bows and a 400 FPS crossbow, the Black Hole 4-Sided Archery Target stands out as the best broadhead target for archery for most buyers. Its 4-sided design, friction arrow removal, and broadhead-friendly foam handled everything I threw at it, and the 8 ounce weight makes it the easiest target on this list to move around the yard.
If you want high-FPS crossbow capability, the Rinehart 18-1 is the cube to beat. For budget shoppers, the Morrell High Roller delivers 450 FPS stopping power with 21 bullseyes. Match the target to your bow speed and shooting location, rotate your aim points, and you’ll have a target that lasts for years of broadhead practice.